Worksheet 03 · L2 — Validation
4-Q Validation Scorecard
Score each question 1–5 after running the AI research loop and 10 user interviews. Three of four strong (4 or 5) to ship. Two strong → narrow ICP. One or fewer → kill or pivot.
Q1 · Pain — does it exist at the frequency you claim?
12345
Signals: search volume · forum / subreddit mentions · 1- and 2-star competitor reviews · support-ticket density on adjacent tools.
Q2 · Density — is anyone already solving it adequately?
12345
Signals: 3 direct + 2 indirect competitors · sentiment gap (positive reviews + open feature requests) · pricing-page taxonomy · churn-cause patterns.
Q3 · Pay — will the specific ICP pay at your target price?
12345
Signals: fake-door landing-page conversion · pre-order pledges · LOI letters (B2B) · existing spend on bad substitutes.
Q4 · Reach — can you find them cheaply, repeatedly, at scale?
12345
Signals: 5 channels where ICP congregates · CAC estimate per channel · low-KD content-SEO opportunities · 5-influencer reach map.
Total score
__ / 20
16+ · Ship. Move to Chapter 6 — pick your stack.
12–15 · Sharpen. One more week of validation on the weak Q.
8–11 · Narrow. The ICP is too broad. Pick a tighter segment.
≤ 7 · Kill or pivot. The brief itself is wrong.
12–15 · Sharpen. One more week of validation on the weak Q.
8–11 · Narrow. The ICP is too broad. Pick a tighter segment.
≤ 7 · Kill or pivot. The brief itself is wrong.