Skip to content
The Handbook
CHAPTER 2

Validation

What it is, why it comes first, and how to read the report you get back

14 min · 7 sections

Validation is the part of PlanMySaaS that is allowed to tell you no. It researches your idea across up to 29 sections, scores each one, and ends with a verdict you did not write. This chapter explains what the machine is actually doing, how to read the result, and what to do when the answer is not the one you wanted. Every screenshot here comes from a real validated idea — UploadEze, a browser extension for fixing file uploads on Indian exam portals.

What validation is

Research with a verdict attached, run section by section.

Validation takes the idea you described and researches it the way a careful analyst would: who has this problem, how badly, how many of them there are, who already serves them, what it costs to reach them, what could kill the business, and what the numbers have to look like for it to work.

It does this as up to 29 separate sections rather than one long essay. Each section is generated on its own, scored on its own, and saved on its own. That matters more than it sounds: a weak section is visible as a weak section, and can be re-run without touching the 28 that were fine.

The result is a report with a score out of 100 and one of three verdicts — Build, Reconsider, or Do not build.

The validation report for UploadEze showing a score of 38 out of 100 and a Reconsider verdict
The validation report for a real idea. The score, the verdict, and the reasoning sit above everything else.
  1. 1The score and verdict — here 38/100 and RECONSIDER. This is the machine's answer, not a summary of yours.
  2. 2The reasoning paragraph names the specific findings that produced the verdict, with the numbers behind them.
  3. 3Section by section lists all 29 sections grouped into the five phases, each with its own quality score.
  4. 4Re-validate creates a new version. The original report is kept for comparison, never overwritten.
What it is
A research report on one idea, made of up to 29 independently generated sections, ending in a scored verdict.
Why it matters
It is the only part of the product that can talk you out of a build. Everything downstream assumes the idea is worth planning — validation is where that assumption is tested.
Can you edit it
Generated. You cannot edit the findings by hand. You change them by changing your inputs and re-running, or by refining a single section.
What it costs
Charged per section as the run progresses. The run pauses rather than failing if credits run out.
Next step
Read the verdict, then open the two or three lowest-scoring sections before anything else.

Why it comes before the blueprint

A worked example of validation earning its cost.

UploadEze scored 38 out of 100 and came back Reconsider. The idea was not dismissed — the research agreed the pain was real and rated its severity 8 out of 10, citing the National Testing Agency naming upload errors as the top cause of NEET rejection.

What it found was a collision between three facts. The pain is real but annual, not monthly, because an aspirant fills 8 to 15 forms a year — which does not fit a monthly subscription. iLovePDF gets 63 million monthly visits from India and earns roughly $1.4M globally, which says Indian file-tool users rarely pay. And founder-market fit scored 28 out of 100.

None of those three facts is obvious from the idea description. Each one costs a few credits to find and could cost months to discover by building. That is the whole argument for running validation first.

Reconsider does not mean stop
It means the current shape of the idea has a problem the research can name. In this example the fix is not abandoning the product — it is testing whether people will pay before writing code, and pricing for an annual rhythm rather than a monthly one. The verdict tells you what to test next.

How a run works

Intake, five phases, one section at a time, then a verdict.

From a sentence to a verdict

1. You describe the idea
A single text box, minimum 40 characters. Longer and more specific is better — the research can only be as sharp as the description it starts from.
2. You answer follow-up questions
A short set of questions about the target user, geography, your own advantage, budget and timeline. These answers are used by every section that follows.
3. Sections run in phase order
Phase 1 problem and customer, phase 2 market, phase 3 competition, phase 4 economics, phase 5 risk, legal and synthesis. Later phases read the output of earlier ones, which is why the order is fixed.
4. Each section is scored
A quality score is attached to each finished section. It measures how well-supported that section's own output is — not how good your idea is.
5. The verdict is written last
Synthesis sections read everything above them and produce the score, the verdict and the reasoning paragraph.

The five phases

PhaseNameWhat it establishes
1Problem & customerWhether the pain is real, who has it, how badly, and whether you are the right person to fix it
2MarketHow many of them there are, whether demand is visible today, and why now rather than five years ago
3CompetitionWho already serves this need, how hard it is to switch away from them, and whether the name is usable
4EconomicsWhat customers will pay, what it costs to serve and reach them, and which channels actually work
5Risk, legal and synthesisWhat could kill it, what the law requires, and the verdict that pulls all of it together
Skipping ahead does not work
Phase 5 sections quote phase 1 to 4 findings by design. Running synthesis on an idea whose problem section never completed produces confident-sounding output with nothing underneath it.

Reading one section

What is on a section page and which parts you can act on.

The Problem Validation section page for UploadEze
Every section page has the same shape: score and status at the top, findings below, navigation to the next section at the bottom.
  1. 1The quality score (81) and status (Complete) tell you how well-supported this section is.
  2. 2The opening paragraph is the finding in one breath — read this first, then decide whether you need the detail.
  3. 3Structured fields like Pain severity 8/10 and Frequency: Annually are what synthesis sections later read.
  4. 4Ask AI opens a conversation about this section specifically, not about the whole idea.

Sections are not free text. Each one produces named fields — a severity, a frequency, a list of personas, a set of channels — and those fields are what later sections consume. That is why a section can be strong on prose and still score badly: the score reflects how well the evidence supports the fields, not how well it reads.

What it is
One research finding with its own score, status, structured fields and supporting reasoning.
Why it matters
Later phases quote these fields. A wrong number here becomes a confident wrong conclusion three sections later.
Can you edit it
Generated. You cannot type over it. You can refine it with feedback, or re-run the section on its own.
What it costs
Re-running one section costs only that section, not the whole report.
Next step
If the score is below 70, open it and check what evidence the section actually found before trusting the number.

Quality scores, and what they are not

The number next to a section measures the research, not the idea.

Every completed section carries a score. In the UploadEze report most sections sit between 74 and 85, with Content & SEO Landscape at 41 and Competitive Landscape at 59.

A low section score does not mean the idea is bad in that dimension. It means that section's output is thinly supported — the research found less than it wanted, or the evidence it did find was weak. The right response is to read that section first, not to average the numbers.

The verdict score at the top of the report is a different number. That one is about the idea.

NumberWhat it measuresWhat to do with it
Section score (0–100)How well-supported this section's findings areOpen anything below 70 and read the evidence yourself
Verdict score (0–100)How strong the idea looks once every section is weighedUse it to decide whether to build, test more, or change the shape of the idea
Status pillWhether the section finished, failed, or was skippedRe-run failed sections; skipped ones were not part of your tier

Changing your inputs and re-validating

How to update a report without losing the one you have.

Ideas move. When your description or your intake answers change, the report that was true last month is quietly stale.

Re-validate creates a new version of the report. The previous version stays saved and readable, so you can compare what the research concluded before and after your change. Nothing is overwritten.

If only one section is wrong, re-run that section instead. It costs a fraction as much and leaves everything else untouched.

Refine before you re-run
Each section can be refined with your own feedback — you tell it what it got wrong or what context it missed, and it reworks that section with your input in hand. This is usually better than a blind re-run, because a blind re-run has no more information than the first attempt did.

Promoting to a project

The moment validation ends and planning begins.

The promote-to-build screen for UploadEze
Promoting carries the validated research into a project so the blueprint is planned against real findings, not the original sentence.

Build unlocks once the report is 50% complete. You do not need a positive verdict to promote — that is deliberate. A Reconsider verdict with a clear test in front of it is a legitimate reason to start planning a smaller first version.

What promoting does is carry the research forward. The project's architecture, features and technical design are generated with the validation findings as context, which is why a promoted project is sharper than one started from a blank description.

What it is
Creating a project from a validated idea, with the research attached as context.
Why it matters
It is the only path that carries validation findings into the build plan. A project created from scratch starts with none of that context.
Can you edit it
The new project is fully editable. The idea it came from stays frozen as the record of what you believed at the time.
What it costs
Promoting itself does not charge. The generations inside the project do.
Next step
Open the project and read Overview before generating anything.